Kandemir: US faces the risk of simultaneous crises involving four rivals

Dr. Osman Gazi Kandemir examines US policy toward China, Russia, Iran and North Korea through the lens of Cold War force planning. He argues that coordinated timing, rather than a formal alliance, is the central strategic risk for Washington.

Analysis of US defence strategy toward four rivals
Text

In Dr. Osman Gazi Kandemir’s assessment, the United States may treat China, Russia, Iran and North Korea as separate files, but the prospect of those states acting during the same period poses a major challenge for Washington’s security planning. Kandemir compares the issue with debates over force structure during the Cold War and argues that the US now faces more rivals with comparatively more limited military capacity.

The article says that, under Kennedy and Johnson, the Pentagon planned its force structure around a “two-and-a-half-war” concept. That calculation envisaged two major wars, against the Soviet Union in Europe and China in Asia, as well as a smaller conflict elsewhere in the world. Kandemir writes that Nixon and Kissinger used the split between Moscow and Beijing in 1969, moved China out of the opposing camp and reduced the strategic model to “one and a half wars.”

According to Kandemir, the Pentagon adopted a post-Cold War benchmark of winning two regional wars at the same time, but reduced that target to one major war in 2018. The source states that the 2026 National Defense Strategy, published in January, also does not regard conducting two major wars simultaneously as a realistic planning objective. Kandemir links the issue to “simultaneity” and notes that FDD’s July publication, “Axis of Aggressors,” warned against treating the four states as unrelated challenges.

The author describes Washington’s approach along three lines: shifting the burden of confronting Russia to European allies and that of confronting Iran to partners in the Middle East, using selective force against Iran, and pursuing diplomacy intended to separate Russia from China. Kandemir says the Trump administration’s effort to engage Putin through Ukraine is known in Washington as “reverse Kissinger.” He argues, however, that the approach will not work because Russia’s war economy is tied to the Chinese market and to dual-use parts arriving from China.

Kandemir also addresses the counterargument that China, Russia, Iran and North Korea do not have a joint command, a common plan or a broad mutual-defence structure. According to the source, a mutual-defence treaty exists only between Moscow and Pyongyang. Even so, the author argues that formal alliance is not necessary for simultaneous action and cites Ukrainian military intelligence information that around 25,000 North Korean troops have gone to Russia or served there on rotation.

Kandemir’s conclusion is that the United States has identified the threat correctly but chosen the wrong remedy. He writes that a burden-sharing strategy would weaken if allies do not make the required investments, and that it would take years for Europe to build forces able to deter Russia on its own. This article contains the author’s strategic analysis and forecasts alongside the facts presented in the source.

LIVENews of the Day